Contributory Infringement for retail-center landlords whose tenants sell infringing Goods

November 20, 2013

Those who encourage, or benefit from, acts of infringement can be held liable just as readily as those who actually sell infringing goods.  The recent case of Coach Inc. v. Goodfellow, 717 F.3d 498, 106 U.S.P.Q.2d 2033 (6th Cir. 2013) is a good example of what can happen to retain-center landlords who do not take the appropriate steps to prevent the sale of infringing items by its tenants.

The Defendant, Goodfellow owned and operated a flea market where vendors sold counterfeit products bearing Plaintiff’s COACH trademarks.  Goodfellow controlled the flea market and had the ultimate authority to allow and remove vendors who sold goods at its flea market.  Goodfellow had previously received various correspondences from COACH and other intellectual property owners as well as the local district attorney general notifying Goodfellow of the counterfeit sales within its flea market.  The Court determined that Goodfellow had knowledge of and willful blindness toward the ongoing infringing activities of its vendors and thereby facilitated those infringing activities.  The Court did recognize that Goodfellow had taken some minor steps to reduce the vendors’ infringing activities but ultimately determined that such steps were insufficient.

The Court affirmed the district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of Coach on the issue of Contributor Infringement and entry of judgment on damages and attorney’s fees and cost.  This was a costly lesson for Goodfellow which could have easily been avoided had Goodfellow sought appropriate legal advice and followed such advice.

For additional information regarding your company’s potential liability for contributory infringement or if you have any other trademark law or intellectual property law questions or concerns, please feel free to contact our office at the telephone number above.

Trademark Law


A trademark is a brand name.  A trademark or service mark includes any word, name...

read more

Copyright law


Copyrights are a form of protection provided by the laws of the United States...

read more

Patent Law Services


A patent is an intellectual property right granted by the Government...

read more

FDA Compliance


The FDA regulates products responsible for about 25 percent of the gross national product...

read more

Business Law


The attorneys at Rick Ruz, PLLC pride themselves on catering to the complete needs...

read more

Office Map

View Larger Map

Office Contact

Ruz & Ruz, PL
255 Alhambra Cir.
Suite 500
Coral Gables, Florida 33134
(P) 1 (305) 921-9326
(F) 1 (888) 506-2833